Meh. Not very nice
First of all, the concept is very nice, an 8/10.
The music: A bit repetive and a bit annoying in some areas. I give it a 6/10.
The boss fight: A bit hard...and long to figure out. Once I figured it out, it took around 5 minutes to kill the boss. I give the boss an 8/10.
Medals: Okay. 7/10.
Saving: Let me see...what is the word for this.....2 things:
In-game: Saving is okay. the postboxes an interactive feature, which I think might not be in any other game I've seen so far. 6/10.
Out-game: (This means loading when you close the browser and open it again, for those of you who don't understand my words :P) Let me see....what's the word for it.....H-O-R-R-I-B-L-E. Especially for a user who was leveling up his abilities a lot (me) and...(BOING! The bomb drops) my browser crashes. WHAT THE HECK???!! Here I am, trying SO much to level up the character's abilities, and my STUPID browser CRASHES!!!! I silently hoped the in-game feature of saving, and when I open it, all my hopes drop to the earth like a stone. NO SAVEGAME DATA!! My life is back to 4 hearts, jump level back to 1, EVERYTHING to 1! And I beat shadow and the day (in-game) wasn't even so much as OVER!!!
Verdict on saving: 0/10. Absolutely horrible. Add this. Please.
On Average: 5.6. If the saving was there, I'd give it an 8 in average.
Oh yeah: Postscript:
"Thanks everyone for all the positive reviews, rates, feedback, oh and being told my game could 'die in a fire' because the boss was so hard. You have to work hard to get that level of frustration out of someone. ^_^" - titch007uk
Well, I can also say this: Your game can also go 'die in a fire', but not because the boss was so hard. It's because you can't load directly. Add a load game option and an "erase data" option and I'd say that your game won't 'go to hell'.
So for the time being: Adios, titch, and the horse you came to newgrounds on :P